"Only variables should be passed by reference" in PHP — What It Means and How to Fix It

What the PHP error "Only variables should be passed by reference" means and how to fix it.

Published November 1, 2026

A function that takes a parameter by reference (like end(), array_pop() or array_shift()) was given an expression instead of a variable.

What it means and why it happens

Functions needing a reference must receive a real variable so PHP can modify it. Passing the result of another function call fails.

Read the full message: it names the file and line where the problem was detected, which is the best place to start.

What you see

run the code
Notice: Only variables should be passed by reference

Practical examples

Code that triggers it

<?php
$last = end(explode(',', $csv));   // result of explode is not a variable

The fix

<?php
$parts = explode(',', $csv);
$last = end($parts);
// or PHP 7.3+: $last = array_key_last($parts) !== null ? $parts[array_key_last($parts)] : null;

Use array helpers

$last = array_slice(explode(',', $csv), -1)[0];

Common mistakes

  • Passing function results straight to end() or reset().
  • Ignoring the notice as harmless.
  • Not storing the array first.

Key takeaways

  • Only variables should be passed by reference: A function that takes a parameter by reference (like end(), array_pop() or array_shift()) was given an expression instead of a variable.
  • Read the message and the line number first.
  • Fix the cause, don't just silence the error.

FAQ

Which functions take references?

end, reset, array_pop, array_shift, sort and others.

How do I find which line caused Only variables should be passed by reference?

The error message and stack trace show the file and line; start there and work backwards.

More PHP articles